New York: Jessica Alba and Martha Stewart have faced criticism over their Halloween 2026 costumes after social media posts featuring the celebrities sparked debate about insensitive costume choices. Alba’s outfit referenced the infamous 1994 attack on figure skater Nancy Kerrigan, while Stewart dressed as a homeless person in an Instagram image that included a sign asking for help.
Both incidents attracted online criticism, although the situations involved different contexts. Alba’s costume revisited a real-life sports scandal involving violence against Kerrigan, while Stewart’s outfit drew attention to the serious issue of homelessness and economic hardship.
The backlash intensified after Stewart issued a second statement apologizing for her costume, describing it as insensitive and not funny. Alba, meanwhile, appeared to remove her Halloween photos from Instagram after criticism over the skating-themed look.
Must Read: Martha Stewart Apologizes After Homeless Halloween Costume Backlash
Jessica Alba’s Halloween Costume Referenced Nancy Kerrigan
Jessica Alba’s Halloween costume became a talking point after she shared photos dressed as former American figure skater Nancy Kerrigan.
The actress appeared with a bloodied bandage around her knee, recreating the visual associated with the 1994 attack on Kerrigan. Alba’s friend was dressed as Kerrigan’s skating rival Tonya Harding, while a baseball bat was used as part of the costume reference.
The images were shared around Halloween celebrations in Los Angeles. Alba captioned the post with a reference to the two skaters, but some viewers criticized the decision to turn a traumatic real-life incident into a Halloween costume.
The 1994 attack occurred shortly before the Winter Olympics, when Kerrigan was struck on the knee by an assailant. The incident became one of the most widely discussed scandals in figure skating history because of its connection to Harding’s former husband and people associated with the attack.
Harding later acknowledged that she had overheard information about the plan, but she was not criminally convicted of involvement in the assault. The U.S. Figure Skating Association subsequently banned her for life.
For critics, the issue with Alba’s costume was not simply its reference to a famous sports story. They argued that the outfit recreated the injury suffered by a real person and risked making light of the violence that affected Kerrigan’s career.
Other social media users defended the costume, arguing that the incident has been repeatedly revisited in documentaries, films and television coverage over the years.
The mixed response highlighted how Halloween costumes based on real-life controversies can be interpreted differently depending on whether viewers see them as pop-culture references or as reminders of personal trauma.
Jessica Alba Appears to Delete the Instagram Photos
The criticism grew after Alba’s Halloween post appeared to disappear from her Instagram account.
Entertainment reports said the photos had been deleted following the backlash, although images from the event continued circulating online and the costume was also discussed on other social platforms.
Alba has not publicly provided a detailed explanation for removing the post in the reports available at the time of publication. Her representatives had not immediately responded to media requests for comment.
The costume was worn at a Halloween party hosted by Vas J. Morgan and Michael Braun in Los Angeles. The event reportedly had a hockey-inspired horror theme, which offered context for the skating-related outfits.
However, the party theme did not prevent criticism from viewers who focused on the historical incident behind the costume.
The situation also demonstrates how celebrity Halloween posts can quickly move beyond their original setting. A costume intended for a themed party can become a broader public discussion once photographs reach a large audience online.

Martha Stewart’s Homeless Halloween Costume Sparks Criticism
Martha Stewart faced a separate backlash after posting an Instagram image of herself dressed as a homeless person.
The lifestyle personality appeared in distressed clothing, a dark hat and makeup intended to make her face look dirty. She also held a sign reading, “I AM HUNGRY HELP ME!!”
The post drew criticism because homelessness is an ongoing social and economic crisis affecting people across the United States. Some viewers argued that portraying homelessness as a costume trivialized the experiences of people living without stable housing.
The reaction was also shaped by the fact that Stewart’s post included promotion for her candle collection, leading some critics to question the decision to combine a serious social issue with a commercial message.
Stewart initially explained that her costume was intended to raise awareness about homelessness. She said the issue remained one of America’s major challenges and noted that she had supported charities working to address it.
However, the explanation did not end the criticism. Some viewers argued that awareness could be raised without turning the circumstances of unhoused people into a Halloween outfit.
The debate became more intense as screenshots and discussion of the deleted post continued circulating online.
Martha Stewart Issues a Second Apology
Stewart later issued a more direct apology after her initial response failed to settle the controversy.
In her follow-up statement, she acknowledged that her earlier comments had not gone far enough and recognized that many people were experiencing financial hardship.
She described the costume as “insensitive and not funny” and said she was very sorry.
The second statement marked a shift from explaining her intention to acknowledging how the costume had affected people who viewed it as offensive.
Stewart also emphasized that homelessness was a serious issue she cared about and that she had spent time supporting charitable organizations addressing the crisis.
The apology received a mixed response online. Some users welcomed her willingness to take responsibility, while others continued questioning how the issue could be addressed meaningfully beyond a public statement.
The incident renewed discussion about the difference between intending to raise awareness and choosing a method that may hurt or offend the people connected to the issue.
Why the Halloween Costume Backlash Matters
The Jessica Alba and Martha Stewart controversies reflect a wider conversation about celebrity costumes and the boundaries of Halloween humor.
Costumes inspired by fictional characters, films or historical events can be received as creative references. However, when they involve real people who experienced violence, poverty or trauma, the response can be more complicated.
Alba’s costume referenced a highly publicized attack that affected Nancy Kerrigan’s life and career. Stewart’s outfit depicted homelessness, a condition that continues to affect individuals and families facing economic hardship.
In both cases, the criticism focused on whether the costumes treated serious experiences as entertainment.
The incidents also demonstrate how social media has changed the public response to celebrity Halloween celebrations. Photos shared for a limited audience can quickly become widely discussed, with viewers interpreting the images through different cultural and personal perspectives.
Neither controversy represents a single, universal public reaction. Some people criticized the costumes, while others defended them or accepted the explanations offered afterward.
Must Read: SEAL Team Viewership 2026: Paramount+ Streaming Numbers Explained
What Happens Next?
As of November 2, 2026, Stewart has issued a second apology, while Alba’s Halloween photos appear to have been removed from Instagram following criticism.
No further detailed public response from Alba was confirmed in the reports reviewed for this article.
The two incidents have placed celebrity Halloween costumes under renewed scrutiny, particularly when they draw on real-life tragedies or social issues.
For Stewart, the central development is her acknowledgment that the costume was insensitive. For Alba, the discussion remains focused on the choice to recreate a real-life sports attack as a Halloween look.
Both stories underline the importance of context when celebrities use real people and serious events as inspiration for costumes.


